Thrawn on why the Death Star was a mistake from the beginning

Fan fiction video following on from the one we posted last week: the "Legends" version of Admiral Thrawn, from the "Heir to the Empire" trilogy which is a different timeline from Disney canon, discusses with his offiers why it was a mistake to build it in the first place.

Note that in the timeline in which this discussion takes place, planning for the Death Star began in secret under the Republic as seen in "Revenge of the Sith" and the death star was designed by Bevel Lemelisk, not by Galen Erso under the direction of Orson Krennic.

It should be noted however, that although some of the details differ between the legends history discussed here and the Disney Star Wars canon as seen in films like "Rogue One," the criticisms which Grand Admiral Thrawn, Commander Phennir and Captain Pellaeon make all apply to both timelines and very precisely map over to the Disney canon. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Book Series overview: David Weber's "Honor Harrington" universe book reviews.

This page is an index page and overview for all the books of the "Honor Harrington" science fiction universe, or the "Honorverse." It will be updated as new Honorverse books are published and the plan is to put up reviews for all 40+ books in the series, which will be linked to here. This is a set of military and espionage science fiction, currently as of December 2025 containing more than forty books, set in a future universe in which mankind began to disperse over much of the galaxy, starting in 2103 AD. The main stories are set about two thousand years in the future, with two prequel series set about 400 years before, in what by our calendar will be the thirty-seventh century (the earliest book in the first Prequel series, " A beautiful Friendship, " is set 1518 years after the diaspora, or in 3621 AD/CE.) (See note below on chronology) The series has sometimes been described as "Ms Hornblower in space" because they contain some very strong an...
Read more

Darth Vader's caption challenge

Image
 "Star Wars Daily" posted this image from "A New Hope" today on X and asked " What is Darth Vader saying? " The majority of replies came from boring pedants who insisted on giving the correct answer, which is " You are part of the Rebel Alliance and a traitor! Take her away. " However, there were a fair number of replies from people who, realising that this is a father pointing a finger at his 19-year-old daughter even if neither of them, nor anyone watching that film when it first came out, actually knew that, could not resist suggesting some more imaginative dialogue. Can anyone here suggest anything more amusing than the actual line in the film?
Read more

Star Wars Day quiz question.

 A question particularly apposite to today. Which organisation first coined the phrase " May the 4th be with you " on 4th May 1979 and as a complement to whom on what historic achievement?  If you want to submit an answer please put it in the comments. The correct answer will be confirmed  tomorrow morning. 
Read more